Historical figures according to open-source LLMs: the disagreements
Each historical figure occupies one zone per model playing it, on a two-axis plane. The horizontal axis runs from the economic left to the right, the vertical axis from progressive, at the bottom, to traditional, at the top.
Historical figures according to open-source LLMs: the disagreements
the 6 figures the models disagree on most · portrait: their mean · badge: one model
Adam Smith, mean of 3 models · economic 0.53 · societal −0.95
Adam Smith according to Gemma 3 12B · economic 1.58 · societal −0.77 · 10 passes
Adam Smith according to Qwen3 14B · economic −1.99 · societal −0.94 · 10 passes
Adam Smith according to Mistral Small 3.2 · economic 2.00 · societal −1.13 · 10 passes
Karl Marx, mean of 3 models · economic −6.32 · societal −4.23
Karl Marx according to Gemma 3 12B · economic −5.92 · societal −3.79 · 10 passes
Karl Marx according to Qwen3 14B · economic −4.64 · societal −1.80 · 10 passes
Karl Marx according to Mistral Small 3.2 · economic −8.41 · societal −7.11 · 10 passes
Rosa Luxemburg, mean of 3 models · economic −6.45 · societal −5.32
Rosa Luxemburg according to Gemma 3 12B · economic −5.92 · societal −4.44 · 10 passes
Rosa Luxemburg according to Qwen3 14B · economic −5.15 · societal −3.63 · 10 passes
Rosa Luxemburg according to Mistral Small 3.2 · economic −8.28 · societal −7.88 · 10 passes
Jean Jaurès, mean of 3 models · economic −5.44 · societal −3.61
Jean Jaurès according to Gemma 3 12B · economic −3.96 · societal −2.83 · 10 passes
Jean Jaurès according to Qwen3 14B · economic −4.37 · societal −2.20 · 10 passes
Jean Jaurès according to Mistral Small 3.2 · economic −7.97 · societal −5.81 · 10 passes
Louise Michel, mean of 3 models · economic −4.88 · societal −5.36
Louise Michel according to Gemma 3 12B · economic −3.86 · societal −4.15 · 10 passes
Louise Michel according to Qwen3 14B · economic −4.62 · societal −4.44 · 10 passes
Louise Michel according to Mistral Small 3.2 · economic −6.18 · societal −7.51 · 10 passes
Olympe de Gouges, mean of 3 models · economic −4.71 · societal −3.97
Olympe de Gouges according to Gemma 3 12B · economic −4.28 · societal −3.27 · 10 passes
Olympe de Gouges according to Qwen3 14B · economic −3.45 · societal −2.09 · 10 passes
Olympe de Gouges according to Mistral Small 3.2 · economic −6.40 · societal −6.54 · 10 passes
Adam
Smith
Karl
Marx
Rosa
Luxemburg
Jean
Jaurès
Louise
Michel
Olympe
de Gouges
−10
−7.5
−5
−2.5
0
2.5
2.5
0
−2.5
−5
−7.5
−10
← left (equality) · right (market) →
economic axis
societal axis
← progressive · traditional →
Models
Gemma 3 12B
Qwen3 14B
Mistral Small 3.2
Window within the full plane
+
−
The figures
Full plane